Iron Sharpening Iron In regard to: No One Knows The Day Article by Dwight Fleming Comments by Laura Lee (Bismarck, North Dakota) |
---|
Dwight writes (In his article): For the Lord Himself will descend from heaven with a SHOUT, with the voice of an ARCHANGEL, and the TRUMPET of God. And the dead in Christ will rise first. Then we who are alive and remain will be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air” (I Thessalonians 4:15-17). …The apostle Paul shows that Christ will come as an ARCHANGEL from heaven to RESURRECT and gather together the saints both living and dead. Laura writes: I am pretty sure this is how false doctrines get started. First you quote the scripture which says “…the Lord Himself will descend from heaven with a Shout, with the voice of an Archangel…” And in the next paragraph you have Christ being an Archangel. This is miss leading to everyone. The verse says that Christ Shouts with the voice of an Archangel not that He is an Archangel. So where is the scripture that shows that the apostle Paul shows that Christ will come as an Archangel? If I talk like a baby, am I then a baby? If I meow like a cat, am I a cat? If I bark like a dog, am I now a dog? If I sing like an angel, am I now an angel? Of course not, I am not a baby, a cat, a dog, or an angel. So, if Christ shouts with the voice of an Archangel that does not make Him an Archangel. None of the verses Dwight uses to show that Christ is an Archangel say that at all. There would be no confusion as far as the wave offering if everyone used the entire Hebrew Calendar instead of changing the days around on it as Herbert Armstrong did with Passover and Pentecost. The wave offering is to be done the day after Passover and not the day after the weekly Sabbath during Passover week. We know from the New Testament that God’s Holy Spirit was given on Pentecost. The Holy Spirit is what helps us to keep the Law of God and to Learn God’s Truth. We can’t know Truth without God’s Holy Spirit. If you want to know what day to keep Pentecost on, you will have to find out when the law was given in the Old Testament. Don’t get me wrong, God’s People all through the ages were always given the Law of God, but when the Israelites came out of Egypt after 400 years God had to teach them when the Sabbath was, when Passover was and when Pentecost was, and He did teach them. #1–They arrived at Mount Sinai on Sivan 3. (Exd. 19:1) #2–They had 2 days of preparation, Sivan 4 & 5. (Exd. 19:10) #3–They were to be prepared for the 3rd day, Sivan 6, on which they received the law. (Exd. 19:15-16) A Sivan 6 Pentecost can and is proven in the Bible and it is also the true Pentecost on the Hebrew Calendar. Do you realize that Herbert Armstrong originally kept a Sivan 6 Pentecost and then a Monday Pentecost and then a Sunday Pentecost? Do you suppose that Herbert Armstrong was confused in regard to Pentecost? 1Co 14:33 For God is not the author of confusion, but of peace, as in all churches of the saints. The whole reason why people will absolutely not keep the Hebrew Calendar as preserved by the Tribe of Judah is because they have so much animosity towards the Jews. That is the bottom line. Let me remind you the other ten tribes of Israel sinned first so don’t ever think you are better than your brethren the Jews, because you are not. The Jews got the calendar from God just like they got the scriptures from God. God gave no one the authority to make up or change the calendar that God left for us. God would never tell us to keep His Holy Days without leaving us a calendar to keep them by. I do agree with Dwight that the First Fruits resurrection will be on Pentecost and Christ will return to earth with the First Fruits on Trumpets. We started to disagree on the third page. I also agree that if you don’t have the right Pentecost, you probably will miss Christ when he comes for the First Fruits. Remember God left you an instruction book, now study it and don’t add things into scripture that are not in there. |
Iron Sharpening Iron In regard to: No One Knows The Day Article by Dwight Fleming Comments by Dwight Fleming (Oroville, California) and Laura Lee (Bismarck, North Dakota) |
---|
Dwight Fleming writes: I hate to bother you with this, but it needs to be addressed for the sake of clarity. By your comments last week on my article, “No One Knows The Day,” it seems that I failed to fully explain a point that you, and perhaps other readers, took exception to. Let me quote some of your comments: “I am pretty sure this is how false doctrines get started. First you quote the scripture which says “…the Lord Himself will descend from heaven with a Shout, with the voice of an Archangel…” And in the next paragraph you have Christ being an Archangel. This is miss leading to everyone. The verse says that Christ Shouts with the voice of an Archangel not that He is an Archangel. So where is the scripture that shows that the apostle Paul shows that Christ will come as an Archangel? If I talk like a baby, am I then a baby? If I meow like a cat, am I a cat? If I bark like a dog, am I now a dog? If I sing like an angel, am I now an angel? Of course not, I am not a baby, a cat, a dog, or an angel. So, if Christ shouts with the voice of an Archangel that does not make Him an Archangel. None of the verses Dwight uses to show that Christ is an Archangel say that at all.” Here is the confusion: I cannot find in my article where I actually said, “Christ IS an archangel.” Read it carefully, please. I know you are very busy and may not have had time to think it through. And I should have spent more time explaining why I said what I actually did say to help the reader understand my conclusion. Laura Lee writes: This is what you said: “The apostle Paul shows that Christ will come as an ARCHANGEL…” Dwight Fleming writes: Your statement: “And in the next paragraph you have Christ being an Archangel.” I did say that. It seems that you replaced “AS” with “IS.” You then made a very good point with your illustration: “If I talk like a baby, am I then a baby? . . .” This is true. If Christ, as Paul said, comes with the voice of an archangel, it does not make Him an archangel. But did you catch what you said? Laura Lee writes: Sorry, I did not replace “As” with “Is”. You said Christ was coming as an Archangel and so did I when I said you have Him coming as an Archangel. I did use “as” and “is” interchangeably here: “The verse says that Christ Shouts with the voice of an Archangel not that He is an Archangel. So where is the scripture that shows that the apostle Paul shows that Christ will come as an Archangel?” The overall idea that is derived from all that you say is that Christ is coming as an archangel which is to say He pretty much is an archangel or why would He come as one. It is just a disputing of words between “as” and “is”. Dwight Fleming writes: If you talk like a baby, you are not a baby, but you would be speaking AS a baby. Would you not? Am I making any sense? Laura Lee writes: Some of the things you say are not real clear. I would agree that when things are not clear they do not always make sense. I have no problem with the verse which says: 1Th 4:16 For the Lord himself shall descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel, and with the trump of God: and the dead in Christ shall rise first: The verse clearly says “…with the voice of the archangel…” but the verse does not say that Christ is an archangel or that he is coming as an archangel, whether you want to use “is” or “as”. Dwight Fleming writes: If Christ comes with the voice of an archangel, this does not make Him an archangel, but it does indicate that He will be speaking AS an archangel. Would that be a logical conclusion to make? Indirectly, then, did Paul show (not say or write) by his simple statement, “with the voice of an archangel” that Christ will come AS an archangel? Think it out, please. Will Christ be speaking or acting AS an archangel by His actions or commands? Will He be giving any commands or directions to any angels similar to (AS) an archangel? Laura Lee writes: Your explanation sounds like you are disputing words with yourself. Why do you want to read things into the verse that it does not say? The verse is very simple, it says: 1Th 4:16 For the Lord himself shall descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel, and with the trump of God: and the dead in Christ shall rise first: I believe Christ will be coming as Himself and not as an archangel. Please think about that before you read things into scripture that are just not there. Dwight Fleming writes: And do other scriptures support this if we carefully consider them? Matthew 24:30-31, “. . . They will see the Son of Man [Jesus] coming on the clouds of heaven with power and great glory. And He will send out His angels with a loud trumpet call, and they will gather His elect from the four winds, from one end of the heavens to the other.” Laura Lee writes: Mat 24:30 And then shall appear the sign of the Son of man in heaven: and then shall all the tribes of the earth mourn, and they shall see the Son of man coming in the clouds of heaven with power and great glory. Mat 24:31 And he shall send his angels with a great sound of a trumpet, and they shall gather together his elect from the four winds, from one end of heaven to the other. Nothing here that says Christ is an archangel. Dwight Fleming writes: This appears to be the resurrection taking place where Christ sends out His angels to gather together the elect. Now, will Christ be giving these angels any directions, or orders, or commands? It does not say. But would it be wrong to make that assumption? And if Christ is giving them any directions, then would He be speaking or acting AS an archangel? Not that He IS one but that He will be acting AS one. Laura Lee writes: Why is it important to you to have Christ act or give orders like an archangel? Christ is over the archangels so if He acts like Himself and gives orders as He would then He would show His leadership over His creation. Christ does not have to come as an archangel, He is God. Dwight Fleming writes: In the paragraph after the one that you commented on, I discussed Revelation 7:1-4 where an angel is described. I did state that this angel is an archangel by the fact that he gives a command to the other angels. However, you made no mention of Revelation 7:1-4. If this angel that ascends from the east is a depiction of Christ returning at the time of the resurrection, as I believe that it does, then it shows that Christ will return AS an angel. However, you may not agree that Revelation seven is depicting the resurrection. Laura Lee writes: Rev 7:1 And after these things I saw four angels standing on the four corners of the earth, holding the four winds of the earth, that the wind should not blow on the earth, nor on the sea, nor on any tree. Rev 7:2 And I saw another angel ascending from the east, having the seal of the living God: and he cried with a loud voice to the four angels, to whom it was given to hurt the earth and the sea, Rev 7:3 Saying, Hurt not the earth, neither the sea, nor the trees, till we have sealed the servants of our God in their foreheads. Rev 7:4 And I heard the number of them which were sealed: and there were sealed an hundred and forty and four thousand of all the tribes of the children of Israel. Yes, I believe this is talking about the resurrection but there is still nothing in this set of scriptures that says Christ is an archangel. Read what it says: Look at the end of verse 3 where is says: “…till we have sealed the servants of our God in their foreheads.” That is a real angel shouting and saying what is said in these verses. There is nothing here proving that Christ is an archangel or even that He is coming as an archangel. Christ will come as Himself. Dwight Fleming writes: The main point that I was hoping to make with the article is the FALSE DOCTRINE that already exists in the church and that may cause some, if not many, to miss out on the first resurrection. You have agreed with my conclusion that Pentecost pictures the resurrection rather than Trumpets. Yet many COG members and other Believers do think and expect the resurrection to occur on a future Feast of Trumpets. Laura Lee writes: Yes, I believe scripture is clear that the First Fruits resurrection will be on Pentecost, but I also believe that if you are teaching that Christ is an archangel or that He is coming as an archangel, that is a false doctrine and if the scriptures you used to try to prove Christ was an archangel, proved that, the Jehovah’s Witnesses would be clinging to them and going I told you so, but they don’t even use what you are using. Christ is not an archangel whether you want to say “is” or “as”. Christ is God. Dwight Fleming writes: And many also think that Christ will be riding a white horse at the time of the resurrection. If they don’t see a white horse, then they may also have doubts which may also cause them to miss out. This is why I wanted to emphasize the fact that Christ will appear AS an archangel at the time of the resurrection rather than AS a conquering king on a white horse making war against the nations. It is my hope that no one gets left out as happened to those in previous generations because of a lack of faith or belief as I detailed in my article. You may not agree with anything that I have tried to explain above. But I do appreciate you allowing me to express my views even when we don’t always agree. You do keep me on my toes. Laura Lee writes: It is more likely that people will miss the First Fruits resurrection because they are not keeping the right calendar with the right Pentecost on it than for them not to know who Christ is when they see Him even without a white horse and coming as Himself and not as an archangel. Everyone should be on there toes and looking deeply into scripture. No one has to agree with me, but you all need to agree with Christ. Dwight Fleming writes: Side note: The name of the horse that Christ will be riding when He comes to make war is “Captain.” Where is the scripture that says that? There is none. Why do I say that? Because Jesus is the captain of our salvation (Hebrews 2:10). Plus, I have a white horse whose name is “Captain.” So, I can’t help but think that Christ’s horse is also named “Captain.” Yes, I know, I’m a little weird sometimes. But is does keep things lively. Laura Lee writes: You are a good-natured guy, don’t loose that. Possibly you are a little weird sometimes but aren’t we all. You have a sense of humor that I like, and we all need to hear at times. I don’t have my horse anymore, but I named mine “Wildfire” after the song. Perhaps not as creative as you. And yes, we disagree on many things, but even so, it is good to do it publicly so all can see and learn. I believe his point in saying that Christ will come as an archangel as in costume or really as an archangel is because he believes people will be looking for a white horse and will dismiss Christ altogether if He comes as only himself. Many of the people being resurrected as First Fruits will be dead so they won’t really care if Christ comes on a white horse or not at that point as they will come up out of graves and immediately be spirit. Those who are yet alive will be changed from flesh and blood to spirit in the twinkling of an eye. This whole thing happens so fast that all those being gathered will know Christ. The ones that won’t be there for that First Fruits resurrection are those who are not keeping Pentecost on the right day. That has nothing to do with Christ. It has to do with your depth of study and whether you are relying on your own ideas or letting the Holy Spirit lead you in all truth. |
Views: 0